Is Andy Cohen the New Jerry Springer?
Why watching the Vanderpump Rules Season 10 Reunion left me wondering if we might have a new “Sultan of Salaciousness” in Bravo’s Andy Cohen.
Culture sensationalism is back in a big way thanks to the Emmy nominated ratings juggernaut that is Vanderpump Rules (VPR) Season 10.
Though I spent decades as an entertainment executive producing reality TV, I had never seen a single episode of this series. Then “Scandoval” exploded and it was impossible to ignore — the show was literally everywhere!
Not wanting to watch 10 full seasons (plus reunions!) I followed the official Bravo catch-up guide provided by my diehard VPR friend (shout out to Elizabeth!) so that I could get up-to-speed quickly. And though I began watching as a cynic, I ended as a fan — this series delivers on the hype.
It all ends with an explosive, 2-part reunion special that has the cast screaming, shoving, storming off set and making sure to not violate a restraining order. At the center of the chaos is host Andy Cohen and the show’s namesake, and absolute icon, Lisa Vanderpump.
Watching the reunion I began to wonder…is Andy Cohen the new Jerry Springer?
For those too young to remember, Jerry Springer rose to prominence in the 1990's with his sensational talk show that often featured heated confrontations, outrageous behavior and a carnival-like atmosphere. It gave rise to reality tv and thrived on conflict, drama, and shocking revelations. It became infamous for its chaotic and often exploitative nature, where guests’ personal issues were put on display for public consumption. Springer’s show played on the darker aspects of human behavior, appealing to those who sought sensationalism. The Jerry Springer Show made a massive impact on an entire generation, myself included.
When I watched the VPR Reunions, I was suddenly transported back to the 90’s. It was compelling, dark, almost dangerous tv that veered very close to the sensationalism that Jerry Springer produced at his peak.
It’s an odd comparison because up until now, there was really nothing to connect Cohen and Springer except the fact that they were both known for their hosting roles. Each always catered to different audiences and offered contrasting approaches. Cohen’s style leans toward fostering a sense of camaraderie, relatability, and shared enjoyment, making him more akin to a late-night talk show host. Springer’s legacy is rooted in the sensational and sometimes lurid spectacle, targeting viewers who are drawn to conflicts and dramatic confrontations.
Those differences almost disappear in the VPR reunions. Most notably watching Andy Cohen physically restrain a cast member to prevent a fight. It was a ratings bonanza — just like The Jerry Springer Show in its prime. Sensationalism still sells.
Mr. Springer, who passed away in April, always argued that he was simply presenting reality, warts and all. As the NY Times noted after his death, “ Springer’s wildly successful show made sport of real people and maintained their exploitation.”
This feels like Mr. Cohen’s territory now. The torch has passed. We’ll watch what happens next.
